ok.com
Browse
Log in / Register

Which 2025 SUVs Earned the IIHS Top Safety Pick+ Award and Why Did Others Fail?

OKer_m4wl3ei
04/12/2025, 07:51:16 PM
Which 2025 SUVs Earned the IIHS Top Safety Pick+ Award and Why Did Others Fail?

The 2025 Tesla Model Y and Volvo XC90 Plug-in Hybrid have secured the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety's (IIHS) highest safety honor, the Top Safety Pick+ award, while the Chevrolet Colorado, GMC Canyon, and Jeep Wrangler failed to qualify due to crash test performance. This distinction highlights the growing divide in vehicle safety as the IIHS implements stricter testing protocols, particularly a new evaluation that emphasizes rear-seat passenger protection.

What Are the IIHS's Updated Crash Test Requirements?

The key change for the 2025 awards is an updated moderate overlap front crash test. This test simulates an offset head-on collision. Previously, it only measured protection for an average-size male dummy in the driver's seat. The new test adds a second, smaller dummy in the rear seat behind the driver, representing a 12-year-old child or a small woman. This update addresses a critical safety gap: while front occupants are well-protected by advanced airbags and seat belts, rear-seat occupants have a higher probability of injury in frontal crashes despite being farther from the point of impact.

To qualify for either the Top Safety Pick or the more stringent Top Safety Pick+ award, vehicles must meet specific criteria across a battery of tests. IIHS ratings are on a scale of good, acceptable, marginal, or poor. The mandatory requirements include:

  • A good rating in the driver-side small overlap front (simulating hitting a tree or pole) and side-impact tests.
  • An acceptable or good rating in the updated moderate overlap front test.
  • Acceptable or good-rated headlights and front crash prevention systems.

The critical difference between the two awards is that Top Safety Pick+ requires a good rating in the moderate overlap test, whereas Top Safety Pick only requires an acceptable score.

Why Did the Tesla Model Y and Volvo XC90 Earn Top Safety Pick+?

Both SUVs demonstrated superior crash protection for all occupants, but they achieved the top award in different ways.

  • 2025 Tesla Model Y: The electric SUV earned high marks across the board. It unofficially ranks as more "plus" because its standard crash-avoidance system earned a 'good' rating in the pedestrian-avoidance test. Its performance in the new moderate overlap test confirmed excellent protection for both front and rear-seat dummies.
  • 2025 Volvo XC90 Plug-in Hybrid: Volvo has long been synonymous with safety, and the XC90 upheld that reputation. It’s important to note that the award applies specifically to vehicles built after December 2024, when Volvo made running changes to the SUV’s rear seat-belt load limiters—a feature that manages the force exerted by a seat belt on an occupant's chest during a crash. This simple change, as illustrated by the XC90, is an effective way to enhance rear-seat safety. The Volvo's crash-avoidance system earned an 'acceptable' rating in the pedestrian test.
VehicleIIHS AwardModerate Overlap Front TestPedestrian Crash Avoidance
Tesla Model YTop Safety Pick+GoodGood
Volvo XC90 PHEVTop Safety Pick+GoodAcceptable
Jeep WranglerDid Not QualifyGoodN/A
Chevrolet ColoradoDid Not QualifyMarginalN/A

Why Did the Chevrolet Colorado, GMC Canyon, and Jeep Wrangler Fail to Qualify?

These models fell short of the award criteria for distinct reasons, primarily related to the new testing standards.

  • 2025 Chevrolet Colorado: The midsize truck earned a marginal score in the updated moderate overlap test. Data from the rear-seat dummy indicated a high risk of injury to the chest and neck. Furthermore, its available headlights were inconsistent; one set scored 'good,' but another available option ranked 'poor.' A vehicle must have at least one set of 'good' or 'acceptable' headlights to qualify.
  • 2025 GMC Canyon: As a mechanical sibling to the Colorado, the Canyon's crash-test results are likely similar. However, the IIHS did not conduct a full test suite. Its eligibility hinges on whether its specific headlight options perform better than the Colorado's poor-rated units.
  • 2025 Jeep Wrangler: The Wrangler performed well in the moderate overlap test with a 'good' rating. However, its eligibility was thwarted by lower scores in the small overlap front crash test and headlight evaluation, preventing it from earning even the standard Top Safety Pick award.

Based on our assessment experience, the IIHS results demonstrate that a vehicle's overall safety is not just about surviving a crash but protecting every occupant with consistent, high-performing systems.

What Should Safety-Conscious Car Buyers Look For?

When evaluating a new vehicle, safety should be a top priority. Focus on models that have earned the IIHS Top Safety Pick+ award, as it represents the current highest standard in crash protection.

  • Check Build Dates: For the 2025 Volvo XC90, confirm the vehicle was built after December 2024 to ensure it includes the updated safety components.
  • Review Specific Scores: Don't just look for the award badge. Dig into the IIHS detailed reports to see performance in individual tests, especially the updated moderate overlap front evaluation.
  • Consider Standard Safety Tech: The best safety features are those that come standard. Prioritize vehicles with top-rated crash avoidance systems and good headlights on all trim levels.

The key takeaway is that the latest IIHS tests have raised the bar, making rear-seat safety a critical differentiator. The 2025 Tesla Model Y and Volvo XC90 PHEV meet this new standard, while the Colorado, Canyon, and Wrangler have areas requiring improvement to keep pace with evolving safety expectations.

Cookie
Cookie Settings
Our Apps
Download
Download on the
APP Store
Download
Get it on
Google Play
© 2025 Servanan International Pte. Ltd.