Which Mid-Size 5-Seat SUV Won the 2019 Challenge?

The 2019 Hyundai Santa Fe Ultimate 2.0T AWD narrowly clinched victory in a comprehensive six-SUV comparison, scoring 353 out of 540 points. Its win was driven by exceptional value, superior cargo versatility, and a straightforward user interface, despite a less refined powertrain. The Honda Passport followed just one point behind, with the Ford Edge, Nissan Murano, Chevrolet Blazer, and Jeep Grand Cherokee rounding out the rankings based on rigorous testing across 17 categories, including comfort, technology, driving dynamics, and family usability.

How Were These Mid-Size SUVs Evaluated?

Our evaluation was based on a week of real-world testing of six popular mid-size, five-seat SUVs. Each vehicle was scored across 17 distinct categories, including front and backseat comfort, interior quality, cargo space, powertrain performance, child-safety seat fitment, safety features, ride and handling, braking, and overall value. The vehicles tested were all well-equipped, all-wheel-drive models with sticker prices ranging from $39,905 to $51,975. The goal was to determine which SUV offered the best all-around package for consumers.

Is the 2019 Jeep Grand Cherokee's Age Showing?

The Jeep Grand Cherokee, largely unchanged since 2014, finished in last place with 300 points. While it boasts impressive off-road capability and a comfortable ride, age-related drawbacks were significant. Its key weaknesses included difficult child-seat installation, disappointing fuel economy, and a high price tag that wasn't justified by its feature content.

• The Good: The Grand Cherokee's ride quality was rated best in the test, effectively isolating passengers from road imperfections. Its Uconnect touchscreen was also praised for being fast and easy to use. It remains the only model with genuine off-road credentials.
• The Bad: The SUV ranked last for child-seat fitment, with hard-to-find LATCH anchors (lower anchors and tethers for children, the standard system for securing car seats) and recessed seatbelt buckles. Its observed fuel economy of 22.2 mpg was among the lowest, and its nearly $52,000 price felt excessive for the experience.

Why Did the Fun-to-Drive Chevrolet Blazer Rank Fifth?

The 2019 Chevrolet Blazer Premier AWD scored 303 points, landing in fifth place. It was hailed as the most fun-to-drive model with sharp handling and a strong powertrain. However, a critical omission of standard safety tech and a high price led to a poor value score.

• The Good: Judges praised the Blazer's engaging handling, confident braking, and potent 308-horsepower V-6 engine. It also offered practical touches like six USB ports (including newer USB-C types) and clever interior storage.
• The Bad: The most significant flaw was the lack of standard automatic emergency braking, a key safety feature expected at its $49,290 price. The ride was firm, and the backseat was criticized for being cramped and claustrophobic.

How Does the Nissan Murano Balance Luxury and Efficiency?

The 2019 Nissan Murano Platinum AWD finished fourth with 317 points. It stood out for its fuel-efficient V-6 engine, top-rated interior quality, and excellent child-seat accommodation. However, it felt dated in areas like handling and cargo utility.

• The Good: The Murano achieved the best observed fuel economy in the test at 26.4 mpg. It earned top marks in our Car Seat Check and its cabin materials were considered a cut above the rest.
• The Bad: Its handling was let down by heavy steering and excessive body roll. It also had the smallest cargo area in the group, limiting its practicality for larger families.

What Are the Ford Edge's Strengths and Weaknesses?

The 2019 Ford Edge Titanium AWD secured third place with 328 points. It impressed with a refined balance of ride and handling, top-tier safety technology, and very comfortable front seats. Its main drawback was an underwhelming base powertrain.

• The Good: The Edge was the only model with adaptive cruise control that works all the way to a stop. Its seats were highly adjustable and comfortable, and it delivered a polished, car-like driving experience.
• The Bad: The turbocharged 2.0-liter four-cylinder engine felt overmatched, especially when using the recommended premium fuel for maximum performance. This also negatively impacted its value score despite decent fuel economy (25.6 mpg observed).

Did the Honda Passport's Practicality Secure Second Place?

The 2019 Honda Passport Elite AWD was a close runner-up with 352 points. It won over judges with superb visibility, a massive and versatile interior, and a spacious, well-appointed backseat. Its score was dragged down by a frustrating infotainment system.

• The Good: The Passport offered the best outward visibility and incredible in-cabin storage. The rear seat was roomy and featured amenities like a sliding function and rear sunshades.
• The Bad: Honda's touchscreen system, which lacks a tuning knob, was universally panned. The push-button gear selector was also found to be unintuitive. The ride was busy, and it lacked some advanced safety features available on competitors.

Why Did the Hyundai Santa Fe Ultimately Win?

The 2019 Hyundai Santa Fe Ultimate's one-point victory was anchored by its phenomenal value proposition. At $39,905, it was the least expensive model yet was packed with features. It also excelled in cargo space and offered the most user-friendly controls in the test.

• The Good: The Santa Fe's combination of a low price, generous standard warranty, and extensive feature list made it the clear value leader. Its cargo area was the most practical, and its dashboard controls—including an excellent touchscreen—were straightforward and logical.
• The Bad: The optional 235-horsepower turbocharged 2.0-liter engine was the model's weak point, described as balky and unrefined compared to other powertrains. However, a standard 2.4-liter engine is available for those prioritizing smoothness over power.

Based on our assessment experience, the 2019 Hyundai Santa Fe represents the most well-rounded choice for most buyers in the mid-size SUV segment. Its strengths in critical areas like value, usability, and technology outweigh its powertrain shortcomings. For those who prioritize a more engaging drive, the Chevrolet Blazer is a compelling option, while the Honda Passport is ideal for families needing maximum space and visibility. Ultimately, your choice should hinge on which vehicle's strengths best align with your personal priorities and driving needs.