Browse
Log in / Register
Share
In a rigorous comparison of seven top-selling models, the 2019 Volkswagen Tiguan emerged as the definitive winner, scoring highest in nine out of sixteen evaluated categories, including seating comfort, interior quality, and driving dynamics.
The compact SUV segment is fiercely competitive, with each model promising a unique blend of utility, comfort, and technology. To determine which vehicle truly delivers on these promises, a team of expert editors conducted a multiday evaluation of the most relevant 2019 models. The test focused on SUVs that were either redesigned or significantly updated since the last comparison. The results reveal a clear champion but also highlight that the "best" SUV often depends on which features are most important to the individual buyer.
The testing methodology was designed to mirror real-world ownership conditions, evaluating vehicles on criteria that matter most to families and daily drivers. Judges scored each SUV on a 1,000-point scale across sixteen categories. The tested vehicles were all higher-end trim levels with all-wheel drive (AWD) and a suite of common features like forward collision warning, Apple CarPlay, and a moonroof. Pricing for the test vehicles ranged from approximately $34,000 to $40,000. The categories included:
The competition was close, with even the last-place model excelling in specific areas. Here’s a breakdown of how each contender performed.
The Verdict: While equipped with modern safety tech, the Rogue shows its age with a noisy transmission and dated interior. The Nissan Rogue proved viable in important areas, finishing second in both safety features and front-seat comfort. However, it landed in last place due to the lowest scores in several key categories. Its continuously variable transmission (CVT), a type of automatic transmission that seeks optimal engine efficiency, was criticized for its loud, delayed response. Judges also noted loose handling and inconsistent interior materials.
The Verdict: A powerful V-6 engine and upscale interior are offset by a cramped cabin and limited cargo room. The Jeep Cherokee’s unique 3.2-liter V-6 engine provided robust, smooth power that stood out in a class of four-cylinders. It also tied for the highest-rated interior. Yet, it was held back by its packaging. The rear seats were uncomfortably tight for adults, and it had the least measured cargo space, making it feel a size class smaller than its competitors.
The Verdict: The redesigned RAV4 offers strong standard safety tech and great fuel economy but is let down by a noisy cabin and firm ride. Toyota completely retooled the RAV4 for 2019, and it finished a respectable fifth. It topped the safety category and achieved the highest observed fuel economy at 29.0 mpg. However, judges found its ride quality borderline rough and its engine unpleasantly noisy during acceleration. The lack of Android Auto integration was also a notable omission.
The Verdict: The CR-V remains a top choice for families due to its massive cargo space and clever storage, but its powertrain and ride feel dated. The Honda CR-V excels as a practical family hauler. It had the most cargo volume by measurement and unbeatable in-cabin storage solutions. However, it slipped in the rankings due to a turbocharged 1.5-liter engine and CVT combination that was slow to respond from a stop and became noisy under load. Its ride quality also tied for the lowest score.
The Verdict: A significant update for 2019 makes the Tucson a compelling all-arounder and the best value of the group. As the least expensive vehicle in the test at $34,130, the Hyundai Tucson offered an impressive list of features, including ventilated front seats and a panoramic moonroof. A new six-speed automatic transmission provided smoother operation than its predecessor. While its fuel economy was tied for lowest, its combination of comfort, features, and price earned it the top spot in the value category.
The Verdict: The Forester is a remarkably well-rounded SUV, doing almost everything well without a single last-place finish. The redesigned Forester was the model of consistency. It didn't score lowest in any category and earned top marks for its excellent visibility, confident braking, and easy child-seat installation. Its well-tuned CVT avoided the drawbacks seen in other models. The main criticisms were overwhelming dashboard controls and vague steering feel.
The Verdict: The Tiguan returns as champion by offering a refined, engaging driving experience without sacrificing passenger space or technology. The Volkswagen Tiguan’s win was decisive. It topped or tied in nine categories, including front and rear seats, interior quality, handling, and powertrain. Judges praised its responsive eight-speed automatic transmission, quiet cabin, and spacious, comfortable seating for five. While it was the most expensive model and its fuel economy was mid-pack, its well-rounded excellence and generous warranty made it the clear winner. Based on our assessment experience, the Tiguan delivered the most premium and satisfying driving experience in the class.
The best choice ultimately depends on your priorities. Use this breakdown to find the SUV that excels in the areas you value most.
Before you buy, always conduct a thorough test drive on roads you typically travel to ensure the vehicle meets your specific needs for comfort, performance, and usability.
